To subscribe to Afterall journal, starting with this issue, please click here.
Alternatively, if you wish to purchase this article individually, you may do so via JSTOR. Please follow the instructions on this page.
What one usually only perceives are contexts that make sense
- never or seldom contexts of non-sense. The Dosenfeld presents
such a context of non-sense, which the viewer of course tries to
alter into a context that makes sense. The viewer's occupation with
each separate aspect makes sense; the aspects in their totality do
not. In seeking intelligibility, these nonsensical situations
usually go unnoticed, even though life is full of
them.1
In 1574 the Mannerist architect Bernado Buontalenti (1536-1608) designed the altar steps for the church of Santa Trinita in Florence.2 Buontalenti, of course, didn't know he was a Mannerist, but he was certainly aware that his mission was to shape the surroundings of the Florentian nobility into the stage set for the living theatre of courtly grace. The function of form in this situation was to express the human arts in excelsis, surpassing nature in sublime complexity, in order that the backdrop thus created would cause the actions of those present to resonate perfectly as they luxuriated in their own reverberating presence and power.
Buontalenti's steps are, literally, fantastic. They face you directly as you approach the altar, rising towards, yet somehow not meeting, the gaps in the ornamental balustrade, their curved stone edges warping in ungraspable ways as if designed in a dream that Gaudi once had about MC Escher. They can do this because they are in fact three-dimensional trompe l'oeil carvings of steps; the actual, usable steps are in the traditional place at right angles on either side of the altar. The illusion is a deliberate reference to the pulpitum, the set of steps that led